8 Sept 2009

Blueprint for Global Derivatives Market

Derivatives are in essence a bet on the price of the underlying asset. Economically they are a zero-sum game where the losing side funds the gains of the successful side. Like all bets the derivative markets serve to redistribute wealth minus the costs of running the market. As a consequence of the credit crisis reform of the derivative markets has moved to the top of the political agenda. This is not the place to discuss the role that derivatives have played in the financial crisis. But if more players are active in a market it can only be expected that moves above (and below) underlying value are exacerbated - despite the fact that derivative instruments are often claimed to help move prices back to their underlying trend. I do not agree that moving all derivative trading to exchanges is necessary to avoid bubbles and excessive risks associated with derivative positions as advocated by many commentators. For an new example see the paper just published by Deutsche Boerse. Instead, I think that higher capital requirements to support open positions will be sufficient to reduce the danger (real or imagined) attributed to derivative markets.

No comments: